No one wants to see an infant sporting the raw, tender skin of a sunburn, but the fear of the sun–like many other parental fears–seems to have become maybe a little hysterical?
Felix and me in Mexico in 2010.
Too Little Sun
The overzealous use of sunscreen on kids has resulted in widespread vitamin D deficiencies, which are linked to cancer, depression, multiple sclerosis, heart disease, and obesity.
A 2009 study found that a staggering 70 percent of children in the United States have low vitamin D levels. An occasional sunburn might be safer!
Toxic Sunburn Protection
Conventional sunscreen is loaded with chemicals, including parabens, well-established carcinogens, and oxybenzone, an endocrine disruptor that may generate free radicals when exposed to ultraviolet light.
Some researchers even suspect oxybenzone to be the hidden cause of the increase in melanoma, although most studies have found no such link. Still, add this potential risk to the risk of vitamin D deficiencies, and standard sun safety doesn’t feel so safe.
Note: These days, almost all sunscreen is free of PABA (para-aminobenzoic acid), and so this once ubiquitous—and possibly carcinogenic—sunblock ingredient is no longer a concern.
My Top Pick for Best Natural Sunscreen
Babo’s spray sunscreen has been a total game-changer for my family, since my kids hate having creams applied. And it’s in a non-aerosol can, and contains nothing concerning.
$21.99 — or subscribe and save up to 6%Buy Now
My Top Pick for Best Natural SunscreenSafer Natural Sunscreen…Maybe
Wolfie and me in Aruba in 2014.
It was long believed that the safest way to avoid sunburn was to use a natural sunscreen that contains “barrier” ingredients, such as titanium dioxide or zinc oxide.
Because the application of such ingredients leaves skin with a telltale white sheen, nanoparticles (teeny microscopic particles) of each are typically used in sunscreen.
Recent research, however, calls into question the safety of these ingredients, as nanoparticles are small enough to penetrate cell membranes (normally, our cells recognize foreign material as an invader and blocks it out).
Nanoparticles of titanium dioxide are linked to DNA changes and nanoparticles of zinc oxide have been shown to generate free radicals.
What’s Bigger Than a Nano?
Instead of nanoparticles, some natural sunscreen producers use “micronized” particles—basically, these are just slightly larger than nanoparticles, but still tiny.
To be exact, a nanoparticle is less than 100 nanometers in diameter, so micronized zinc oxide or titanium dioxide must be larger than this.
A particle must be 50 nanometers or less to penetrate a cell membrane, by the way. Theoretically, micronized particles should be safe, although at this point you’re probably feeling skittish about all sunscreen!
If You Do Get a Burn…
Most “aloe” gels contain very little, if any, actual aloe vera. This one does, and it offers a soothing solution for sun-exposed skin.
Sensible Sunburn Protection
Given all the confusing information on sun safety as well as sunscreen safety, the ideal scenario would be something like this:
Take your child outside each day for ten or fifteen minutes, and then seek shade. This way, you’ve prevented vitamin D deficiencies as well as sunburn. Obviously, this isn’t always possible, and fortunately there are several brands of sunscreen that you can feel good about using.
Better Than Sunscreen: Sun-Protective Clothing
From hats to full body suis, I like Imse Vimse’s line of non-toxic SPF 50 clothing.
For what it’s worth, my kids are super pale, go outside daily, never wear sunscreen unless we are at the beach or outside all day, and don’t seem to get sunburns. Their grandfather is black, though, so maybe those genes help even if they didn’t present themselves in any obvious way!
Bottom Line on Natural Sunscreen
We sell natural sunscreen in our online store, but I still tell my private clients to let their kids get some sun! Of course I’m not a pediatrician, and you should talk to your own about this—but I think it’s unnecessary and potentially harmful to keep children slathered in sunscreen year-round–even if it’s safe, natural sunscreen.
(Read more about natural sunscreen in our blog post on nanoparticles of zinc oxide and melanoma.)
Felix and Wolfie in sun-protective shirts in Costa Rica, 2018.
Okay, I’m done preaching. Here’s some info on the Good Stuff when it comes to natural sunscreen (plus the Bad and the Sneaky Stuff).
The Good Stuff: Natural Sunscreen
3rd Rock Natural Sunblock for Kids
I haven’t tried this brand myself, so I cannot speak to how easily it goes on or well it works–but the ingredients are all safe.
Acure Organics SPF 30 Baby Sun Stick
If you’re an Acure fan, you’ll love one of the newer baby products in their line-up, this sunscreen stick. It contains no chemical sun-blocking ingredients (instead using non-nano zinc oxide), and it contains no other questionable ingredients, additives, or preservatives.
Unfortunately, Acure discontinued its entire baby line, including sunscreen!
All Good Natural Sunscreen
I’m partial to All Good’s spray version, but their sport sunscreen is great because it offers 80 minutes of water resitance. Both versions use non-nano zinc oxide to block the sun, and contain no other ingredients of concern. Many of the ingredients are organic in All Good, so bonus points for that!
$22.00 — or subscribe and save up to 10%Buy Now
Babo Botanicals Clear Zinc Natural Sunscreen
Babo’s SPF 30 Clear Zinc Sunscreen Lotion uses non-nano, non-micronized, and more or less clear zinc oxide (meaning less white sheen).
NEW for Spring 2016: Babo now also makes a spray-on, 100% zinc sunscreen, which does not contain sodium benzoate.
$19.99 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
Babo Botanicals Clear Zinc Sport Stick
Unlike their lotion, Babo’s SPF 30 Sportstick does NOT contain sodium benzoate. It also utilizes non-nano, non-micronized, clear zinc, and is perfect for lips, ears, faces, and babies. I find myself using it on arms and legs, too, as it is the least white off all the Good Stuff.
$10.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
California Baby Sunscreen
California Baby sunscreens contain more synthetic ingredients than most of the other Good Stuff on our list. Still, CA Baby contains just titanium dioxide rather than chemical sunscreen ingredients, and overall I consider it a safe option.
MADE OF Broad Spectrum Sunscreen
Made Of’s Broad Spectrum Sunscreen uses non-nano zinc oxide instead of chemical sunscreen ingredients. What sets this brand apart is that Made Of tests their products for contamination with heavy metals, parabens, microbes, and more.
Soleo Organics Natural Sunscreen
Soleo makes a line of baby-safe sunscreen, consisting of organic ingredients and free of fragrance and parabens. While the label claims that the zinc oxide it contains is “non-nano,” it doesn’t specify the size of the particles, so it’s probably micronized.
Soleo sunscreen doesn’t go on completely clear, but is less pasty than Badger or Honest.
You can buy Soleo sunscreen on Amazon for $24.
Green Goo Solar Goo Sun Protection Stick
For those of you who LOVE Green Goo (formerly Sierra Sage) like I do, here’s another product from the one of the country’s oldest herbalists. Solar Goo’s simple recipe includes just seven organic ingredients–including soothing calendula flowers to condition the skin.
Solar Goo goes on relatively clear thanks to a generous infusion of coconut oil. I use this on my face, and it’s also great for small babies.
$9.99 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
Badger Natural Sunscreen
Badger makes a range of sunscreens, all of which are mineral-based and without any Bad Stuff.
-The Baby Sunscreen offers a great non-nano zinc cream.
-For the face, we love the Damascus Rose formula, which has a subtle, pleasant scent.
-For a sunscreen that doubles as insect repellent, Badger makes an SPF 34, DEET-free formula.
-Badger’s sport formula resists water and sweat for 80 minutes.
$15.99Buy Now
Kabana Green Screen
This is definitely the very best stuff, from a safety perspective.
Kabana’s Green Screen uses non-nano, non-micronized zinc oxide (so yes, it goes on a bit white). While the sunscreen itself may not be totally transparent, Kabana certainly is–they list the actual size of their zinc oxide particles right on their website, and I’ve had a number of great conversations with Kabana’s founder, Erik (he’s surprisingly accessible and obviously sincerely devoted to his mission of producing safe, green skincare).
Kabana Green Screen is available in SPF 20 or SPF 35, and the latter even contains vitamin D to combat what you’ll lose by using sunscreen. I sort of like using a sunscreen that goes on white, too. I wrote about why in a blog post last summer. You’ll pay around $19 for a four-ounce tube of Green Screen.
$19.79 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Buy Now
Honest Company Natural Sunscreen Lotion SPF 30
From a non-toxic perspective, some of Honest’s products are better than others, and this is one of the very safe ones. The zinc oxide used as a barrier ingredient may be micronized, but it is non-nano, and none of the other ingredients in Honest’s formula are concerning.
The downside? This sunscreen is extremely thick, pasty, and white. I don’t mind it too much, but my husband likens these sorts of sunscreens to applying toothpaste to the kids’ skin.
Adorable Baby Natural Sunscreen
I was sent a sample of this sunscreen years ago, and I gave it to my friend, Elleni, who was a new mom. She loved it and has remained loyal to the brand. While it’s very greasy, she said she prefers that over a sticky, chalky zinc-based formula (such as Honest or Badger).
At $25 for 4 ounces, Adorable Baby Sunscreen is expensive, but it’s easy to apply and contains no concerning ingredients.
Buy Adorable Baby Sunscreen on Amazon.
Goddess Garden Sunny Kids Natural Sunscreen Spray
While normally I am not a fan of anything you spray on (because of course then you’re inhaling the ingredients), the contents of Goddess Garden are safe enough that I feel comfortable recommending this sunscreen. However, it gets a 3 on Skin Deep, which is higher than most of the products I recommend. Goddess Garden uses micronized zinc oxide and titanium dioxide in its formulas. Update: Now Babo makes safe spray sunscreens, I would choose those over Goddess Garden.
The spray bottle is $20 on Amazon.
Beautycounter Protect Sunscreens
Beautycounter’s Protect All Over Sunscreen includes a lot of ingredients, including phenoxyethanol (the Protect Stick Sunscreen does not contain phenoxyethanol). Overall, as is the case with many Beautycounter products, these sunscreens seem safe to me, but they do contain more ingredients than some of the other brands recommended here.
Poofy Organics “The” Sunscreen
Poofy makes a cream as well as a stick sunscreen. Both have entirely safe ingredients in them, including jojoba oil, shea butter, and only non-micronized zinc oxide as a sun barrier ingredient.
Thinkbaby Sunscreen
This isn’t the very top of my list because it does contain more synthetic ingredients than some of the other natural sunscreens in this list–and nothing is organic. That said, it doesn’t contain synthetic sun-blocking ingredients, parabens, phthalates, or anything else toxic.
Note: Choosing a lower SPF sunscreen, while increasing the risk of sunburn, may combat vitamin D deficiencies, as will delaying application for ten minutes or so after going outside.
We hope you’re enjoying this post! Sign up for our newsletter to be alerted when we publish or update our Safe Product Guides.
christine says
What are your thoughts on Blue Lizard? Thanks
Joy says
That’s what we use I was t sure if she was saying it was sneaky and didn’t give a reason way so I looked it up on reg: http://www.ewg.org/enviroblog/2016/05/22-best-scoring-sunscreens-kids
Maia James says
Hi there-
They are Sneaky Stuff, unfortunately.
Stephanie says
I recently saw a new sunscreen (to me at least it is new lol) named thinkbaby. It was rated a 0 on the think dirty app, but I wanted to see your thoughts. We currently use badger, but I like that I can find this in the grocery store.
Thanks in advance!
Ps I couldn’t find where to comment, hence the “reply” ?
Maia James says
It’s fine, but I do think Badger has an even cleaner ingredients list. Also anything I’ve listed under The Good Stuff:)
Meg says
I’m on vacay in Mexico using thinkbaby. No sunburns but i won’t be applying it to my baby’s cheeks again. He rubbed it in his eyes and he cried for a minute. Using it on my skin though, dries clear ish!
Rach says
My baby has very sensitive skin and we use Vanicream products to soothe eczema. Any thoughts on their sunscreen?
Maia James says
I consider Vanicream to be Sneaky Stuff:(
Crystaline lopez says
What would you suggest for sensitive skin 6 months old and ezema prone?
Maia James says
I’d try the Solar Goo: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/sierra-sage-solar-goo-sun-protection-stick/
Katie says
Maia, which brand do you use for yourself and your husband?
HBP says
What about beautycounter products that are rated well from EWG (http://www.beautycounter.com/body-hair/sunscreen/protect-stick-sunscreen-spf-30-sweet-tooth.html)?
Maia James says
Yes, Beautycounter is Good Stuff! In particular we love their makeup. We are now Beautycounter consultants, in fact:) http://www.beautycounter.com/suzanneweaver-goss/
kathryn says
what about California baby
Maia says
It’s pretty good although it contains a longer list of ingredients than some of the other options.
Robin says
What about Thinkbaby?
Maia James says
It’s Okay, with dimethicone being the only ingredient I don’t love.
Meg says
Thank you for the info!
Wendy says
I love your website!!! What do you think can i use for my seven month baby?
Maia James says
Hi there! I would go for one of the Babo sunscreens–even the stick would work for a baby that small. Or the spray option is great: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/babo-botanicals-sheer-zinc-continuous-spray-spf-30/
Ashley says
What do you think about sunscreen for scalps??? Can the tv good spray sunscreens be used for that??
Ashley says
the good stuff* Idk how “tv” got in there lol
Maia James says
Yes, any of the Good Stuff would be fine on scalps.
Heleana says
Love your website!!
My baby will be 4 months at the beginning of summer here. What sunscreen do you recommend for a baby that young?
Thanks!
Maia says
Hi there-
You should definitely check with your doctor in terms of sunsreen on a baby that young, but in my opinion the very gentlest brand is this one: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/sierra-sage-solar-goo-sun-protection-stick/
Niki says
I love your website it makes my life of research so much easier.
I had ordered the solar goo for my 9 month old. But the several call outs about contacting poison control if ingested kind of freaks me out. What ingredient would this be fore? All my baby does is stick her hands, arms, feed etch in her mouth.
Thanks
Niki
Maia James says
I reached out to the woman who makes Solar Goo and here is what she had to say: “Great question. It is standard on the Drug Fact Panel to state this on all packaging. From our research all of our ingredients if rubbed into the babies skin and if absorbed it is okay if her/him hands and feet are in their mouth off and on. If the child were to eat the whole stick or tin then that is where it would be appropriate to call regarding the ingredients due to the amount.”
Erica Krohnberg says
Hi what do you think of lush products?
Maia says
Don’t know that brand, but will look into it!
Meg says
Lush is not marketed for babies but it is our fave for bath time.
Mindy says
What about Alba Botanica spray sunscreen?
Maia James says
Unfortunately, this is Sneaky Stuff (it has all those chemical sunscreen ingredients I recommend you avoid, above).
Tina says
I love your website, and really appreciate you sharing your research and knowledge with other mommas out there that just want whats best for their little ones! 🙂 how do u feel about the new/ reformulated honest company mineral sunscreen spf 50?
Maia says
The ingredients seem fine, Tina. Some people are just turned off by Honest in general, following the laundry detergent “scandal”: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/honest-detergent-contains-sodium-lauryl-sulfate-after-calling-it-toxic/
Jennifer Schaperow says
Do you think the honest company mineral sunscreen spf is safe for a 7 month old baby. I bought the Babo but it is so thick and hard to spread and seems to come off on any surface it touches. Thanks!
Maia James says
I think the Honest sunscreen is fine. I assume they’ve fixed the formula by now after the scandal.
Lindsey Lutz says
Hi!! Thank you so much for all the information. Your website has been a Godsend over the last 8 months with our new little one. I am about to order the new Babo spray. Do you feel the spray is fine for an 8 month old? I know in the past you have mentioned you didn’t love sprays because of the fact that we breath it in. Thank you!!
Maia James says
Yes, these sprays don’t spray the same way an aerosol can of Coppertone does. You don’t inhale it (you’ll see what I mean when you try it).
Ella says
Hi, how about Mustela – bebe-enfant?
Maia says
Mustela is Bad/Sneaky Stuff–it has parfum, petroleum products, and lots of other synthetics.
Amy says
Hi!
I’m trying to decide between the Babo and the Acure, both in spray. The Babo advertises “Sheer”, can the same be said for the Acure? I tried the honest company spray last year (out of desperation for something quick and easy) and it still sprayed on thick white. Thanks!
Maia James says
The Acure doesn’t come out of the canister clear (no mineral sunscreen will), but it’s very thin and when rubbed in does not leave a white sheen.
Ragini says
Any recommendations from the good stuff list for an Indian baby, 7 months old? (I mention race because our skins react differently to the sun, that’s all 🙂 )
Maia says
Hi there! I’m sorry but my babies are so fair (despite a Caribbean grandfather!) that I really only have experience on very white skin. I would ask your pediatrician for specific recommendations, but I imagine any of the Good Stuff would be appropriate for an Indian baby:).
Aarti says
Hello Ragini, have you had any luck? Thanks! -Aarti
Heather says
What are you thoughts on Earth’s Best and Sinology Kids Sunscreens?
Heather says
Also, what are your thoughts on 3rd Rock?
Heather says
Sorry! Autocorrect – should be Sunology*** Kids
New York mama says
What do you think of trukids?
Maia James says
I just checked out their ingredients, and at first glance it looks fine.
Meg says
I was looking at the babo sunscreens on their website, and it doesn’t list sodium benzoate as an ingredient for the lotions. Are they new formulas, or am I missing something?
Maia James says
It’s been removed! We’ve just updated the site accordingly.
Leah says
What do you know about Coppertone Kids Tear-Free SPF 50?
Maia James says
Unfortunately, it’s Bad Stuff:(
Heather says
Thoughts on Sunology Kids?
Maia James says
I’m not a big fan. Their sunscreen has a lot of ingredients, many synthetic. I think there are better options.
Angelina says
What are some alternatives to neosporin for kids scrapes and cuts to disinfect ?
I want to put together a little first aid kit for my kids would love some advice on this
Maia James says
I’m obsessed with this stuff: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/sierra-sage-green-goo-boo-boo-balm/
Kim says
Hi! Any thoughts on ThinkBaby? After a first glance, and considering it was an emergency/quick purchase, I’m hoping you don’t tell me it’s a sneaky one… it’s rated a 1-2 on EWG but the data is limited. Thank you for all you do!!! Your formula evaluation relieved so much of my anxiety when my supply dipped below my son’s needs. I really appreciate how thorough you are!
Maia James says
I don’t think it’s Sneaky per se, but I do think the other brands listed are better.
Jennifer says
I love Babo products but found their sunblock too thick to apply on my squirming kids. The spray would be a game-changer. You don’t have any concerns about young children inhaling the spray? My youngest are 2 years old and 6 months old. And in practice is it as effective as the lotion?
Maia James says
We’ve found it to be totally effective and a game changer. It’s not aerosoled mist like other spray sunscreens, so no concerns about inhalation. You’ll see when you try it.
Talisha Benson says
What are your thoughts on majestic pure baby sunscreen? The website is http://www.majesticpure.com.
Ingredients
Active Ingredient: Non-Nano Zinc Oxide – 24.7%; Ingredients: Grape Seed Oil, Organic Sunflower Oil, Caprylic/Capric Triglycerides (from Coconut Oil), Organic Beeswax, Organic Cocoa Butter, Organic Shea Butter, Stearic Acid (from Palm Oil), Purified Water
Maia James says
This looks totally safe:)
Betty Ann says
Hi there, I LOVE your website! There are so many types of Badger sunscreen. Does it matter what one I purchase? I’m looking for a sunscreen I can use on myself and my 6 month old baby. I was looking at Badger Unscented Sunscreen Cream. But I see there is also a Badger Chamomile Baby Sunscreen Cream. Do I need this “baby” sunscreen in particular, for use on my 6 month old? Thank you so much.
Maia James says
Any of the Badger line is safe for kids and adults–but ask your pedi for a baby that young:).
Jennifer says
Hello,
A friend just told me about the Honest Co. sunscreen… but after reading the ingredient list, I am not 100% convinced because there are a couple ingredients that I researched and it’s making me question how natural the product is. Do you have feedback on this brand?
Also – I found this brand today (http://bellybuttonsandbabies.com/) that I really feel confident about regarding it’s safety and purity after reading the ingredient list. I would like to know if you’ve heard of it and any feedback you may have.
Thank you 🙂
Maia James says
I actually reviewed the Honest Co. sunscreen in this guide. I don’t know the other brand, but will add to my list!
Qzan says
I love Belly Buttons & Babies sun screen, it has the most production and less ch locals then other brands. The only issue is it has expiration date. It only lasts a year.
Amy says
What about BlueLizard? Of sneaky stuff, what makes it so?
Maia James says
I wouldn’t call it Sneaky exactly, but I don’t love that it has phenoxyethanol and a PEG chemical. Overall, still a decent choice.
Tobi says
Acure for 9 month old versus Babo, do you have a preference and why? I have actually been using Badger, but I feel like she got too much color and I applied pretty liberally.
Maia James says
They really are both great. My top pick would actually be Kabana because it has the added vitamin D. https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/kabana-green-screen-d-organic-spf-35/
Clara P. says
Do you have any recommendations for insect repellents for babies? I’ve been looking through your site (love it!) and can’t find any. Thank you!
Maia James says
Hi there-
You can ask your pediatrician, but I would feel fine using this: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/sierra-sage-organic-bugs-be-gone-spray/
I used it on my own kids since they were babies.
Julie says
Hi Maia,
What are your thoughts on the Rocky Mountain Sunscreen (either the SPF 30 or 50)? http://www.rmsunscreen.com/128OunceGallonSPF50Kids.aspx
I found a score of 3 on EWG.org for the SPF 30 version but I am not sure if that is the “natural” version that is listed. http://www.rmsunscreen.com/images/2015_website/PDF/RMS%20SPF30%20Natural%20Ingredients.pdf
Can you tell me if you have heard of this brand or if the ingredients look safe to use on a infant and toddler?
Thank you for all the hard work that you do and all the great information you provide!
Julie
Maia James says
The natural version looks fine to me!
Tania says
Hi, what do you think of Coola Baby Suncreen?
Maia James says
Looks like Good Stuff:)
Taylar says
Hi there!
Would you mind suggesting an effective, non-toxic sunblock that I could use in the desert in July in Death Valley, California? I am fair skinned and have sensitive skin that is prone to breakouts. (All of this sounds like a dangerous combination, right?!) I’m trying to be as prepared in advance as possible! Thank you for any suggestions!
Maia James says
Any of the brands recommended in this guide would be effective. If you want something with less of a white sheen, I prefer the Babo spray version: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/babo-botanicals-sheer-zinc-continuous-spray-spf-30/
Robin J. says
Hi Maia,
Of the two Good Stuff sprays, are either ‘lighter’ in terms of avoiding pore blockage? I’ve been a Greenscreen loyalist for years but just last week our 2-yr old enjoyed more beach time than usual and after 2 days of liberal Greenscreen use he developed a heat rash, we think because his skin couldn’t breath in the heat. He also has milder eczema so we were perplexed on the conflicting remedies (moisture for eczema, dryness for heat rash).
Wondering if anyone else has experienced the same and were more successful with either spray. Thanks!
Maia James says
They are probably about the same; the Babo one does seem to spray out a bit lighter.
Robin J says
Thanks again Maia!
Kadie says
Maia,
What do you think of Dr. Mercola’s broad spectrum sunscreen? It says it has no nanoparticles.
Thanks!
Kadie
Maia James says
I can’t recommend this one because it contains retinyl palmitate. Here’s why that’s bad: https://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/the-problem-with-vitamin-a/
Angela Williams says
Hello! What are your thoughts on the Sun Bum products?
Maia James says
Unfortunately, I don’t consider this Good Stuff as they use chemical sunscreen ingredients such as avebezone rather than mineral barriers like zinc.
Angela Williams says
This one looks like a newer sun bum product, called sun bum signature. Would this still be considered “bad stuff”?
http://shop.trustthebum.com/sun-bum-signature-spf-30-sunscreen-3-0-oz/
Maia James says
While this contains zinc (a mineral form of sunblock), it also has chemical sunscreens in it, so I would call it Sneaky Stuff:(
Octinoxate
Hadleigh says
I’ve been looking for a natural alternative to a low spf sunscreen. I like to tan(I know it’s bad but a tan allows me to not use other chemical laden things like make up.) Normally at the beach I use a SPF 15 and sometimes a SPF 4 – 8 on my legs, and can’t find any natural product that are that low. I did find Tropical Sands, have you ever used them, are they good? I would like to use something to keep me from burning but still allow a tan to develop. I’ve also heard of using just plain coconut oil for sunscreen does that really work?
Maia James says
I know people who’ve used just coconut oil and swear that it works but I haven’t tried it myself. I just checked out Tropical Sands, and it looks like Good Stuff!
Rebekah says
Is the Honest spray sunscreen also OK or just the lotion? Thanks!
Maia James says
It’s also okay.
Rachel says
We are going to the beach and my baby will be 10 weeks old. I bought him the clothing that has spf in it and have a hat and will keep him in the shade, but was wondering if you think I should also put sunscreen on him and if yes, which type. You mention that you like Kabana Green Screen the best for kids but under the Good Stuff you specifically mention that Babo Botanicals is good for babies. Any thoughts? We are going to Florida (the Gulf side where Zika has been detected one time) and while it is my best intention to keep us and the baby covered with light clothing, any advice on using a bug spray on us or the baby? I saw that you recommend a kind with chemical in it for adults due to the Zika Virus but what about baby? Thank you so much for your time! And your website…we really appreciate you doing the leg work on all these products!
Maia James says
Thanks so much for your kind words:). I’m glad the site has been useful! I do worry about Zika for babies (my husband hosts a podcast that interviewed a doctor on this topic: http://stemcellpodcast.com/ep-65-zika-virus-stem-cells-featuring-dr-arnold-kriegstein)…I would ask your pediatrician if a picaridin insect repellent is safe for your baby (I have this one: http://amzn.to/2bEI9My). Otherwise you could try a natural option, which would be better than nothing, but which needs to be reapplied often. As for sunscreen, the main reason I like Kabana is because it contains vitamin D (which is absorbed transdermally, and might offset the deficiencies caused by our avoidance of the sun and sunscreen use!). Babo is also a great choice;)
Alice says
What about Cotz sunscreen line SPF 40 ?
Maia James says
Don’t know that brand, but will look into it!
Janna K says
Hi- Just wondering if 5 months old is too young for sunscreen?
Maia James says
I would ask your pediatrician before applying sunscreen on a child that young, but for my own children I did use Kabana Green Screen on them.
Astha says
What products of earth mama should I avoid?
Maia James says
In my opinion, all Earth Mama products are Good Stuff:)
Majda says
Brand new sunscreen product- -Patent Pending-
Sunblocz and Sunblocz Baby+Kids, 100% Natural, Mineral Suncreen http://www.sunblocz.com
Majda says
Brand new sunscreen product- -Patent Pending-
Sunblocz and Sunblocz Baby+Kids, 100% Natural, Mineral Sunscreen http://www.sunblocz.com
Mkhana says
Hi there, please share your thoughts on Banana Boat, Thinkbaby or Cerave sunscreen for 16 month old with sensitive skin. He gets sunburned so easily: we are African living in a moderate climate in Nairobi but his cheeks and bridge of his nose get that shiny burnt look…and I am so worried! We were given Neutrogena sunscreen but after checking out your site, learning about oxybenzone, I got more diligent about what I put on his skin. Someone brought us cerave spf 45 from the US but I didn’t like the ingredients in their lotion from before…please advise us!!
Maia James says
Of these, the only one that I consider okay is Thinkbaby.
Stephi says
Love your site! What about La Roche Posay? Many thanks!
Maia James says
I’m not a fan of the ingredients in this one–lots of synthetics, including PEG chemicals.
Victoria says
Thank you soo much for your thorough research Maia! I am so appreciative and loving your site. I would be so interested to know your thoughts on the best natural bug sprays!
Maia James says
Hi there! I wrote about this here: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/whats-wrong-with-insect-repellent/
Ana says
Be careful about anything labeled non-nano zinc that looks clear. THERE IS NO SUCH THING.
It gets confusing because these labels are just claims. The FDA has no laws about nano-particles in personal care products. And heads up, micronized products contain nano-particles. This is because micronized particles range from 70nm-300nm in size. Anything under 100nm is a nano-particle. The EU and Australia have laws about what percentage of micronized particles can be nano-sized before you can make a non-nano claim. The US does not. To add to the sordid mix, a company in Australia makes a “non-nano” zinc that is actually nano-sized particles that are then “glued” together to make a more clear looking sunscreen product.
If all of this gets overwhelming or if you just hate chemistry and always have, just remember this one fact: There is no “special” or “proprietary” method that can make non-nano zinc clear. If a sunscreen has true non-nano zinc, it will have a whitish cast. And for me, that is preferable to risking DNA damage from nano-zinc in my sunscreen.
Lauren Boettcher says
Hi what about Matter Company Baby Sun Care Creme
ngredients:
Active Ingredients: Zinc Oxide 20%
Other Ingredients: helianthus annus* (sunflower seed oil), calendula officinalis* (pot marigold) flower, hypericum perforatum* (St. John’s Wort) flowers, simmondsia chinensis* (jojoba) seed oil, sesamum indicum* (sesame)seed oil, camellia oleifera* (green tea) extract, vitis vinifera* (grape) seed extract, glycerine (vegtable), butyrospermum parkii * (shea butter), tocopherol (vitamin E), xanthan gum, leuconostoc (radish root ferment filtrate), deionized water, essential oils of lavandula angustifolia (lavender), citrus aurantium dulcis (orange), pelargonium graveolens (geranium), cymbopogon martini (palmarosa) and menthe (mint).
*Certified organic
Says essential oils naturally repel against insects?
Maia James says
Nothing looks alarming in this list of ingredients:).
Claudette says
Hello,
After reading about your suggested options for the least toxic sunscreen spray I am still unsure which might be best for my kids. They are 11 and 5 and have only ever used California baby , however after so many years of traveling to the Caribbean and having to apply every 30 min and as thick as it is I would LOVE a spray option . Rubbing the thick white lotion son their little sandy bodies is torture for them and us… what would you suggest in sprays that would need the least rubbing in and provide the best protection… we are all very fair skinned.
Thanks for your time .
Claudette
Heather says
Maia, thank you so much for your research and making it available to help so many of us! I am wondering – what do YOU use for a daily facial sun protection?
I appreciate your feedback.
Maia James says
Hey Heather-
How horrified will you be to learn that I DON’T use a daily sunscreen? I live in the northeast and want to get all the vitamin D I can! When I’m at the beach, I use this stick all over my face: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/babo-botanicals-clear-zinc-sunscreen-sport-stick-spf-30/
I don’t wear much makeup, but if I wanted a daily SPF product I would go with this: https://gimmethegoodstuff.org/store/beautycounter-dew-skin-tinted-moisturizer/
Catherine says
What about Kiss my face baby?
Jackie says
Hi there! Any thoughts on the Substance Baby Natural Sun Care Creme? Thanks!! 🙂
Laura says
Hi Maia, your product guides and research are the best. I look forward to every new update I receive! I was gifted “Hampton Sun for Baby” and was wondering if it’s “good stuff” or if one of the sunscreens you list is better. The ingredients I think are fine (listed below) but I wasn’t able to find if it has nano-particles. My daughter is 6 months and I’m also concerned about sunscreen irritating her eyes and getting in her mouth since her hands, feet, etc. constantly touch her face. Hoping you have time to respond, thanks in advance!!
Active ingredients: Titanium Dioxide 6.0%, Zinc Oxide 12.0%
Inactive ingredients: Beeswax, Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Oleosomes, Chathamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Seed Oil, Chamomilla Rectita (Matricaria) Extract, Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower)
Maia James says
Hi Laura!
These ingredients look fine, although as you mentioned, if it doesn’t specify non-nano then it probably isn’t.
Sushil Karwa says
What do you think about Thinksport Kid’s Safe Sunscreen SPF 50+? It is top rated by EWG skin deep database with a “1” rating for quite a few years in a row. Its free of biologically harmful chemicals like avobenzone, oxybenzone, paraben, phthalate, paba and UV chemical absorbers.
Would you rate this as “Good”, “Bad” or “Sneaky” stuff?
Regards,
Sushil
Audrey Powell says
Are all of these sunscreens good to use in the water? Which stay on the best?
Maia James says
I like the Babo spray best
Kadie says
What do you think of the 100% pure Yerba mate mist? Here are the ingredients that were on their website:
active ingredients: Zinc 12 % Inactive ingredients: Bentonite, Butyloctyl Salicylate, Caprylhydroxamic Acid, Caprylyl Glycol, Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Seed Oil, Cetearyl Alcohol, Coco Glucoside, Vegetable Glycerin, Heptyl Undecylenate, Ilex Paraguariensis (Yerba Mate) Leaf Extract, Jojoba Ester, Methyl Dihydroabietate, Water
Thanks!
Maia James says
Meh, I don’t love this list–lots of synthetics.
Kadie says
Ok, thank you for looking at it! I’ve been using the badger cream sunscreen for my 19 month old, but was looking for a spray. Which one is best for kids?
Majda Ficko says
New 100% Natural Sunblocz- SPF 50
Sunblocz is a safe and natural alternative to chemical sunscreens
• Safe – contains 100% all- natural ingredients
• Effective – 50+ SPF, Highest sun protector factor
• Broad Spectrum UVA & UVB protection
• Very water resistant – 80 minutes
• No Artificial Fragrance
• Hypoallergenic – safe for sensitive skin
• Does not sting eyes
• Repels mosquitos and bugs
• Clinically tested per FDA OTC Sunscreen Monograph regulations
• Dermatologist recommended
• FDA Registered
• Patent Protected
Meg says
I recently bought some of the Babo spray sunscreen, but I am somewhat confused as to why you say you don’t have any concerns over inhaling it. I sprayed some on myself to test it outside and there was a slight breeze and it seemed like it created a mist that got picked up in the wind. When you use it do you never see any type of mist? Thanks!
Kandice says
How do you feel about Zebs Organic Sunscreens? Here are the ingredients…
Non-Nano Zinc Oxide 12%; Coco nucifera* (coconut oil), Olea Europaea* (olive oil), Sunflower Wax, Vitellaria paradoxa (shea butter), Helianthus Annuus* (sunflower oil) – *indicates organic ingredients
Thanks!!
Stacey Coffey says
Hi Maia,
Thanks for all of this wonderful information! What are you thoughts on Thinksport Kid’s Safe Sunscreen SPF 50? (seeing as i just bought 3 of them : /)
Also, any recommendation for tics? I bought a lint roller (sticky ones) because I hate to add yet another products to roll all over my babies!
Thank you!
Stacey
Evelyn rosas says
Hey there! I found RAW elements eco formula spf 30 at the store and EWG had a great 1 rating for it. I think, if I read all the ingredients correctly, it’s a good choice; what do you think?
P.s j have bought many items off your store and have been so glad with them all–mainly the water filter set up and baby wipes!
Julie Gulemi says
Thank you so much for all your research! It is helping me so much to change my own life and the lives of other around me.
I was wondering if you knew about the Glossier products. They have a sunscreen that I just purchased for daily use on my face under my makeup. I have been using beautycounter sunscreen but only for the beach! I’d love to know your thoughts. Thank you so much!
Julie
Laura says
Hi,
Thank you so much for all of your posts. You have helped me make so many decisions in choosing products for my baby! I have an 8 month old baby with eczema. I was using blue lizard but would like to switch to a waterproof sunbmscreen that goes on smooth. I’m considering Trukid sport. Any ingredients I should be concerned with here? Also, any thoughts on how easy to apply it might be?
Allyson Martin says
Hi,
Have you looked at Trader Joe’s new sunscreen stick? http://www.traderjoes.com/digin/post/mineral-sunscreen-stick
I bought the Babo Botanicals sport stick on your recommendation but I think this might be a less expensive alternative brand? Is TJ stick Good Stuff?
Amanda says
Could you please share your thoughts about the cancer council’s products.. Specifically the kids formula.
Thank you!
Danielle says
What about arbonne?
Sara A Goegeline says
Here’s the thing about vitamin D deficiency in adults: you must get a blood test. You must ask your doctor to prescribe as much vitamin D as you require (maybe you don’t need any.) You must take the vitamin D if you need it. Melanoma is serious. I’ve had it. A wonderful woman I know died from it. It’s more aggressive in men than women. It’s not a pleasant death.
In addition to adequate sunscreen, everyone (especially babies) should be wearing sun-protective clothing — not a tee shirt, not a regular straw hat. Melanoma takes about 40 years to develop. Protect your babies and children before they know to protect themselves. Latest info shows greatest danger for skin cancer in the scalp, neck, feet, and ankles–especially for women.
Do your readers a favor and stop harping on vitamin D deficiency and wimpy levels of SPF.
Alejandra says
Hi Mia,
Is it possible to buy through your shop online the Bali Bloc SPF 30 Pure Vanilla Sunscreen Stick 100% fron Kabana.???
Jessica says
What is your opinion on Baby Bum sunscreen?
Thanks!
Heather says
What about Arbonne baby sunscreen?
Julie says
Hey!
I LOVE your site and it has been so helpful. What are you thoughts on SunBum and Glossier Sunscreen? Thank you so much!
Beth says
Do you have an opinion on alba botanical, kids mineral sunscreen spf30… I know it has some not so good stuff in it but I am so new to all this stuff I don’t really know what to look for. We bought this on a trip because we really had no other options.
Diana says
Hi Maia,
As the season turns to sun again, I just wanted to add another option into the mix: Mad Hippie’s Facial SPF. https://www.madhippie.com/products/facial-spf
From what I can tell, it’s safe, but I’m interested to hear your opinion. I use it for my face and love it.
Thanks!
Maia James says
yes, looks good to me;)
Katie says
Hi!!
I’m hoping you can help. My 2 year old and I have terribly sensitive eczema prone skin and most sunscreen burns our skin, especially our faces. After much trial and error I had great luck last summer with Vanicream sunscreen but just found out that due to issues with their suppliers they will not have anything in stock until Oct 2018!! I would love to find an SPF 50+ physical sunscreen (not chemical) Do you have any suggestions? The only other one that doesn’t burn is Neutrogena Pure and Free Baby- is that one safe? (I’m pretty sure the answer is no, but it’s approved by the National Eczema Association, and says that their new formula is free of all chemicals, fragrance, parabens, phthalates, and dyes )
Aarti says
Hello Katie, have you had any success? I am just now considering the possibility that my daughter’s recent sunburns and eczema have been induced by the sunscreen. Thank you.
Karisa says
I picked up a sunscreen the other day called Bare Republic mineral for my children . I was just curious on your opinion .
Arielle says
curious about raw elements sunscreen? Everything I’ve researched seems to put it on your good stuff list but its missing.
Kim says
Hi, I see you have several Babo Botanicals products listed on the safe list. Babo Botanicals just came out with a new product called Baby Skin Mineral Sunscreen – SPF 50. Can you tell me if this is also something you would recommend on your safe list and will you be selling it in your online store?
Aarti says
Thanks for the information. While I understand why clean ingredients are important, what I don’t understand is whether the recommended sunscreens have been tested for true sun protection. I live in AZ, so it’s important to have effective and safe sunscreen
Jessica says
Any thoughts on Beyond Coastal?
IS says
I just discovered this sun shield stick, MyChelle.
https://www.mychelle.com/products/sun-shield-stick-spf-50-tinted
It sounds great marketing-wise, but is it really “good stuff”? What do you think about the use of chia seed oil in terms of phytoestrogens? Safe to use on little boys/men? What are your thoughts on cannabis sativa seed oil? Thanks!
Meghann says
I would love to hear your thoughts on Devita solar sunscreen….
Delpha says
Just adding in another request for a review on SunBum’s baby bum sunblock and Glossier. Love your site!
Katie says
Maia, what brand do you use for yourself and your husband? Sunscreen always makes my face sting, and vanicream was my favorite. I’m sad to see that it’s sneaky stuff…
Samantha says
Hello,
Thanks for the helpful list! Just when I think I’m buying the good stuff, I learn about something else. Although, I’d rather know better so I can do better 😊. I just became aware of ‘hello bello’ and I was wondering if you deemed that a good/safe sunscreen?
Thanks!
Ashley says
Hi Maia,
Thank you for such an amazing guide! Do you have any recommendations one way or another regarding European sunscreens (using Tinosorb)? I was not a frequent sunscreen user but my extra fair skinned babies led me to Avene and Vichy brands.
https://www.eau-thermale-avene.sg/suncare/sunscreens/sun-protection-sensitive-skin/spf-50-lotion-for-children
AVENE THERMAL SPRING WATER (AVENE AQUA). C12-15 ALKYL BENZOATE. DICAPRYLYL CARBONATE. METHYLENE BIS-BENZOTRIAZOLYL TETRAMETHYLBUTYLPHENOL [NANO]. WATER (AQUA). GLYCERIN. BIS-ETHYLHEXYLOXYPHENOL METHOXYPHENYL TRIAZINE. DIETHYLHEXYL BUTAMIDO TRIAZONE. DIISOPROPYL ADIPATE. BUTYL METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANE. CETEARYL ISONONANOATE. LAURYL GLUCOSIDE. POLYGLYCERYL-2 DIPOLYHYDROXYSTEARATE. DECYL GLUCOSIDE. BENZOIC ACID. CAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE. CAPRYLYL GLYCOL. CITRIC ACID. DISODIUM EDTA. GLYCERYL BEHENATE. GLYCERYL DIBEHENATE. HYDROGENATED PALM GLYCERIDES. HYDROGENATED PALM KERNEL GLYCERIDES. POLYACRYLATE-13. POLYISOBUTENE. POLYSORBATE 20. PROPYLENE GLYCOL. SORBITAN ISOSTEARATE. TOCOPHEROL. TOCOPHERYL GLUCOSIDE. TRIBEHENIN. XANTHAN GUM.
Jamie says
Hello Maia,
I saw another question about this brand as well, but I’m very curious about the hello bello brand, it’s available at Walmart which is super convenient for us and it seems reasonably priced. It almost seems to good to be true. Just curious on your thoughts.
Thank you
Jamie
Jenny says
What about blue lizard super sensitive? It’s low on the ewg rating? I know it’s different than the regular blue lizard
Jean says
Hello, this is a great guide. Do you have any thoughts about Juice Beauty’s Spf30 oil free mineral sunscreen?
Kim says
Hi, I see you have several Babo Botanicals products listed on the safe list. Babo Botanicals just came out with a new product called Baby Skin Mineral Sunscreen – SPF 50. Can you tell me if this is also something you would recommend on your safe list and will you be selling it in your online store?
Maria says
Hi Maia, how come all the good stuff has such low SPF protection? We live in Miami and my kids are exposed to sunlight every day, ALL YEAR ROUND. Any good products with higher SPF protection? I’m looking for higher than SPF50. THANKS!
Sara Goegeline says
Don’t you grownup ladies need sunblock/screen. I use two matte brands with different benefits on my face and a different (cheaper) one on my body. I also wear sunblock clothing and hats. Of course, I take vitamin d year-round .in amounts prescribed by my doc after blood work.
What products would you recommend for me, in and out of swimming?
Julie K says
Hi Maia,
Id love a recommendation on the best kids sunscreen that is also considered eco friendly (good for the reefs, biodegradeable) and if possible sunscreen that exists in a recyclable container. Does this unicorn of a sunscreen exist?
Ethan says
Here’s an option that looks like it may be good stuff. My family doesn’t have much need for sunscreen, but this is what we use when we do. What do you think?
Butterbean SPF 30 Simple Formula Sunscreen
https://www.butterbeanorganics.com/collections/butterbean-organics/products/butterbean-spf-30-simple-formula-sunscreen?variant=3014315713
Active Sunscreen Ingredient: Non-nano Uncoated Zinc Oxide 22%
Inactive Ingredients:
*Olea europaea (Olive Fruit) Oil, * Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil, Limnanthes Alba (Meadowfoam) Seed Oil, * Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil, *Butyrospermum Parkii (Fair Trade Shea) Butter, *Cera Alba (Beeswax), *Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Tocopherol (Sunflower Vitamin E)
*Certified Organic Ingredients
Their other sunscreen products have some potentially questionable ingredients in addition to what’s in the “simple formula.”
Cindy cordosi says
What about banana boat? It says a lot less chemicals but contains paragons. I just bought those before I read your article should I ditch it ?
Cindy says
Sorry banana boat does not contain parabans
Kim says
Hello! What are your thoughts on the brands Coola and Avasol? Thank you in advance 🙂
Hermine Tsarukian says
Hello PLEASE tell us what ur thoughts are on BABY BUM spf 50 stick? Also have u heard of HAMPTON SUN SPF 70 for kids???
Please reply
Laura V. says
Hello, thank you so much for the summary and research on sunscreens. I wanted to ask if you’ve read the Clean Label Project sunscreen study? They mention a concern regarding the lead found in mineral sunscreen (especially for toddlers) and now I’m beyond confused what to use for my daughter. Here is the link:
https://cleanlabelproject.org/wp-content/uploads/Sunscreen_Infographic-01-1.jpg
Thanks for your opinion on that!
Katie says
Hey Maia! Have you looked into raw elements? Their kids line seems awesome.
Terri Naughtin says
Hi Maria
I also need a stronger sunscreen especially for my face. I burn in 10 minutes. Can you recommend anything that is at least 50? What about CeraVe? Please let me know. I’m 60 and I sure don’t want premature skin aging!
Thank you.
Terri
April Ciervo says
Any evaluations of Sun Bum Sunscreen?
Linda says
I’m loving the stick sunscreens for my little kids. Just got the Babo sport stick on your reco and love it – it’s clear! I also just got the Waxhead stick. It goes on more white but says it’s reef safe and only 4 ingredients. 1) 25% non-nano Zinc Oxide, 2) Certified Organic Extra Virgin Coconut Oil, 3) Certified Organic Beeswax, 4) Certified Organic Vanilla Extract. What do you think of Waxhead?
Nadia says
Ever heard of Raw Elements? It’s sold through Thrive Market. Just wondering if they seem like a good bet (for kids).
Jennifer Little says
I was looking at hello bello sunscreen, it appears to be fine. What are your thoughts?
Asha says
As a Black woman with Black children, I find most of these sunscreens leave a white cast on our skin. Any feedback on Blackgirl Sunscreen products? They have a kids product as well.